Gutfeld then became editor in chief of Stuff, increasing circulation from 750,000 to 1.2 million during his tenure. A year later, he was replaced by David Zinczenko. He was promoted to editor in chief of Men's Health in 1999. In 1995 he became a staff writer at Men's Health.
He then worked as a staff writer at Prevention magazine and in Emmaus, Pennsylvania, as an editor at various Rodale Press magazines.
After college he had an internship at The American Spectator, as an assistant to conservative writer R.